Controversial Mammogram Guidelines
Tuesday, November 17th, 2009By Shari Einhorn
Do we or don’t we? It’s the question lots of Long Island women are now asking themselves about mammograms.
The American Cancer Society recommends annual screening using mammography and clinical breast examination for all women beginning at age 40.
But on Monday, a government panel made up of doctors and scientists came out with NEW guidelines.
The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recommends AGAINST yearly mammograms for women between 40 and 49. The panel said routine screenings should begin at age 50 and after that — women should go EVERY OTHER YEAR.
The news did not sit well with longtime breast cancer survivors and activists that I spoke with today.
Lorraine Pace from Breast Cancer Help had this to say.
“I am outraged that the U.S. Department of Health would play a numbers game with women’s health. Early detection saves lives and every life is worth it, despite the costs to the healthcare system and concerns about a woman’s potential anxiety.
“Coming on the heels of the current healthcare debate, one has to ask if this is how healthcare panels will ration early detection screenings and life-saving care. Do we really want bureaucrats in Washington making these calls, rather than a women’s physician.
“In one fell swoop, they are trying to wipe out over 20 years of progress in promoting awareness and early detection.”
Karen Joy Miller from the Huntington Breast Cancer Action Coalition said this.
“The debate on mammograms and more importantly cancer still rages on and we’re a long way from a decision on when to get a mammogram. While breast self exam is important, seeking out healthcare practitioners who will provide an extensive clinical breast exam is crucial.”
Hillary Rutter from the Adelphi NY Statewide Breast Cancer Hotline said this.
“I think it’s all about money…and limiting women’s options for screening. I think it’s going to result in more lives being lost.”
And Geri Barish from Hewlett House had this to say.
“New Guidelines for Mammography have just pulled the rug out from under us–we now have over 2 MILLION Women survivors and one of those reasons is early detection. Line us up and see those of us who found our tumors by self breast exam at 40 or early forties even though mammography’s may have not seen anything-Today, along with Mammography we have ultrasound as part of the new protocol-I am angry that we have handed our women a death sentence-told them not to worry after 75. When you are that statistic you don’t take chances-what will this do to insurance issues, the healthy women’s partnership program and the confusion to so many who may or may not be at risk? Education and awareness have been part of our daily language-finding cancer early is our future. Has the government just closed that door? On a daily basis we see women who are in their early forties, thirties and have found early cancer-We are not God-how dare anybody tell us take your chances-it may never grow? Would they?”
I’d love to hear your thoughts?
Shari